jane iredale Mystikol Powdered Eyeliner Reviews | LovelySkin
Dermatologist owned & operated. Visit Schlessinger MD
Free 2-3 day delivery most orders, no minimums
LovelySkin
Today's Special Offer: 20% Off Customer Appreciation Sale + $12 LovelySkin LUXE Gift Shop Now
Return to Product Details
jane iredale Mystikol Powdered Eyeliner - Dark Topaz

Reviews For jane iredale Mystikol Powdered Eyeliner

$26.00
76 Reviews
February 02, 2025

Cruelty Free & Convenient

I don’t like eye liner pencils or liquid eyeliner, so I have just been using dark eye shadow with a liner brush for years, but was looking for a cruelty free alternative that would be easily to travel with. This liner is perfect for me because it creates a natural look and lasts throughout the day and I love that the brush is built in to the container.

Profile Photo

LovelySkin Customer

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

February 01, 2025

Great eyeliner

This is my second purchase of this eyeliner. The amethyst is such a nice color, very flattering, not too dark, yet adds a nice dimension to the eyes. I would definitely recommend to a friend.

Profile Photo

Lemonlily

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

June 15, 2024

Mystikol Powdered Eyeliner

Since I was introduced to this shadow a few years back it’s become my absolute favorite eye definer! It truly appears mystical on defining my eyes. Stays on for hours HIGHLY RECOMMEND

Profile Photo

LovelySkin Customer

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

February 16, 2024

Favorite liner

My favorite liner goes on so smooth and lasts all day.

Profile Picture for Cristina

LovelySkin Customer

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

January 28, 2024

wonderful eyeliner

I love all Jane iredale productsand this eyeliner is amazing. So easy to use and has great staying power.

Profile Photo

LovelySkin Customer

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

May 03, 2023

Love this!!

After years of using the Black/Grey pencil I thought I’d try the Mystikol Powdered Eyeliner. It is awesome and so easy to apply. Though I’m still trying to perfect the look, I will continue to use it. I like the smoky quartz as it is similar to the Black/Grey pencil but doesn’t need sharpening.

Profile Photo

LovelySkin Customer

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

April 23, 2023

Love this eye liner!

After reading some of the reviews both good and bad, I decided to give this a try, so glad I did! I tried it both with and without eyelid primer, stays sooooo much better with primer. I love the little brush and it is very easy to apply. It is a gel but goes on as a powder, it is very smooth, no clumping at all. Can’t wait to order more colors.

Profile Photo

ReggieW

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

February 18, 2023

Happily surprised with this product.

I I was very skeptical initially about ordering this product. I was concerned that the product would go on thick and clumpy. But to my happy surprise it was very easy to apply and the product went on in a very thin line. The brush that was on top of the product was very precise and went on without any problems. I would definitely recommend this product to anyone who would like an eyeliner / shadow that goes on very smoothly.

Profile Photo

sweetpea4

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

October 27, 2022

Third color

I can’t say enough about this liner! It is different than any other liner. It is my favorite because of ease of use - you can’t mess it up! It is powdery & stays in place. You can add to it to make it more intense. I like it because it is subtle. The colors are great. The design is very cool with the brush housed in the top. Love!!

Profile Photo

LovelySkin Customer

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

October 21, 2022

Love the brush!

This eyeliner is so easy to use. The brush is one I will keep and use on other eyeshadows. The color I bought is purple and it is a beautiful, deep color. I haven't tried it as an eyeshadow although I remember reading that it can be used as such. I will probably order another color too because I do like the consistency and ease.

Profile Photo

melemond

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

October 16, 2022

Love this eyeliner!

I've ordered and used this product multiple times. I love the way it goes on and stays until you take it off

Profile Picture for Melissa

MelissaJ

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

September 28, 2022

I really like this eye liner

I love this. It goes on so easily. My favorite is the grey color.

Profile Photo

DJW

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

July 22, 2022

I Love jane iredale Mystikol Powdered Eyeliner!

I absolutely love the jane iredale Mysikol Powdered Eyeliner! I started using this product many yrs ago, before it was changed to the way the eyeliner and brush are set up now, and I've always loved the product!!! The liner goes on so very easily and smoothly! The brush is so very easy to use and get a perfect line under and over the eye. It's so easy to have the line go on very thin or thicker if you prefer. I always plan on using this product. And I love the colors available. All are very flattering to one's eye colors and skin tone!!!! Thank you so much jane iredale for such a great product!

Profile Photo

Beeps

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

June 23, 2022

Where has this been all my life?!

Finally! An eyeliner that goes on so smoothly and quickly and blends so easily. Love the color, the small, soft precision brush and the fact that the brush is contained in the jar's top. I will definitely purchase again.

Profile Photo

LovelySkin Customer

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

January 07, 2023

Getting used to using

I've always used liner in pencil form, so this has taken a bit of getting used to. The color is great, the texture also very good and easy to work with. The brush on the product is fab, great shape that allows for thin to thick as desired. The more I use it, the more I like it!

Profile Photo

LovelySkin Customer

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

December 22, 2022

Okay

This would probably have worked better for me if I had someone else to apply it. I had to apply and wipe to get a thin even line. Then, it left a gray area keeping the line from being a clean line.

Profile Photo

Pegs

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

December 02, 2024

ok not great

i like the concept but the product applies pretty dry and flakes easily

Profile Photo

LovelySkin Customer

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

June 01, 2024

Doesn’t last on me.

I like the concept and the way this goes on. It looks great when first applied, but just didn’t last or stay put on me, even with eyelid primer.

Profile Photo

Suz1

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

March 24, 2024

Powdered Eyeliner

I love the cream to powder for ease of application. I was disappointed that it didn’t last more than 4 hours for me. Also seemed to irritate my eyes. I love Jane Iredale products, but won’t purchase this again.

Profile Photo

Rae

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

January 12, 2023

It's Complicated

The first few times that I used this liner I used special brushes that I have because I didn't realize it has an applicator in the wand. Then, I used the supplied applicator with so-so results. The consistency is quite dry, and I have not received the results that I'm looking for. I am not practiced enough with liquid liner to see a repeatable effect. My eyes are my best feature and I can work magic from Ru Paul to librarian but I only found this product to be frustrating.

Profile Photo

LASusan

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

Have you purchased this product? Write a Review


Return to the top
402-697-1100
Need Help?
Let's Chat
Customer Care Hours
Mon - Fri 9 - 5 p.m. CT
Sat (chat only) 9 - 3 p.m. CT
Sun / Holidays Closed
Call or Text:402-697-1100