Jane Iredale Eye Pencil
I ordered the black/brown pencil. The color is rich and very pretty, and the pencil is creamy and goes on smoothly. However, it does not stay put and is not long lasting. I use it on my upper lashes and sometimes in the waterline. By the end of the day I find that the color has migrated to below my lower lashes, and there is not much remaining on my upper lashes. I find that Jane Iredale products are usually high quality, but, for this price, I would not buy this product again.
LovelySkin Customer
Verified Purchase
Pros and Cons
Pros: this has to be one of the most non-irritating liners I have ever used. It's great for sensitive skin and eyes. Cons: it does not have the staying power that some other eyeliners have. It's great for using if I'm only going out to dinner or something where I don't have to worry about it lasting all day.
WineLuvr
Verified Purchase
Color transfers....
I bought this eyeliner in Midnight Blue with the hope of being able to wear pencil eyeliner that doesn't make my eyes itch. I have tried so many other pencil eyeliners 'for sensitive skin' but none of them have worked for me. I love the color of this pencil, its silky application, and most of all, the fact that it does not make my eyes burn. The downside is that the color transfers to my upper eyelid and fades quickly (I have hooded eyes, for reference). It could be a good option if you are going for a less defined, smoky eye look. I don't think I will buy other colors.
SusanaSR
Verified Purchase
Mixed Feelings
In one sense I like this eyeliner in that the color is very natural, can easily control how light/heavy/dark of a line you want and it doesn't bother my eyes like so many eye liners do. On the other hand I'm disappointed that I can't just make one quick smooth line. I have to go back and forth in order to get an even line and throughout the day it starts to smudge and come off. May buy it again simply because I'm sensitive and would recommend for that reason only. Otherwise, not entirely sure.
LovelySkin Customer
Verified Purchase
Very Average
There isn’t anything special about this eye liner. Unfortunately, it is not long wearing. Would not buy again.
LovelySkin Customer
Verified Purchase
Nice pencil, great color, but doesn't wear long
I'm a Jane Iredale fan, and I do like this pencil after I first apply it. The Taupe shade, especially, is very natural and it applies without much tugging. However, the color doesn't last long and has to be reapplied throughout the day. My eyes tend to be watery in the dry winter weather,so maybe this is my problem. But I've had better luck with BareMinerals pencil liners in terms of lasting wear. The Jane Iredale eye pencils are nice quality, of course, but this is definitely not a long-wearing, smear-proof liner.
Cynders
Verified Purchase
Eyeliner
Tried my first Jane Iredale Eye Pencil in navy. Went on smoothly and very pretty color. Negative one star because it ran/smudged. I put the eye pencil on my top lid only, and a couple hours later, it was under my bottom eye lid. I don't have oily enough skin for this to happen.
LovelySkin Customer
Verified Purchase
Jane Iredale Eye Pencil
It doesn't stay on. I have tried to use powder after applying the Eye Pencil but still doesn't stay on. Not sure I should have even given it 3 stars. I use Jane Iredale for all my makeup, so don't believe it is due to using different products together.
LovelySkin Customer
Verified Purchase
White Liner
Big fan of Jane Iredale products. Ordered their white eyeliner to use to line lower lids to "brighten" eyes. Read an article in a magazine that suggested this. The white liner idea doesn't help. I have no other use for snow white eyeliner, so waste of $$
LovelySkin Customer
Verified Purchase
jane iredale eye pencil
Well nice color but not enough staying power for me. Midday I was reapplying and it would smudge some. Not a fan.
LovelySkin Customer
Verified Purchase
Jane Iredale eyeliner pencil
I love the way the pencil glides on smoothly with no tugging. The color just does not stay on all day and wears off. Is great for sensitive eyes.
LovelySkin Customer
Verified Purchase
Jane Iredale Eye Pencil
The eye pencil goes on well, but I cannot wear it every day because it makes my eyes itch and water.
LovelySkin Customer
Verified Purchase
good product, but not for me
I will return to a liquid liner, this is perfect for women who like the softer look.
LovelySkin Customer
Verified Purchase
Review Summary
Have you purchased this product? Write a Review
