Filtered by: Contains "" Clear Filters
Every time I've explored for a better one, I've wasted my money.
When I ran out of my Jane Iredale brown/black eyeliner stick, I thought maybe I should try something different because it's been years since I first found it. I decided maybe it was no big deal to ignore if another liner wasn't as "clean". I bought a trendy and not cheap liner "created" by a famous person. Although it is a nice product and well made, it was far too color-intense. I'm not a city girl going to dance clubs with "night time makeup", and I'm not a model. So I had no use for that stark look. I'm also not a woman who doesn't use any makeup though. So I re-ordered the Jane Iredale for the 10th time (it is long lasting but it has been ten years since I first discovered it), but I made the mistake of ordering brown instead of black/brown & it was not dark enough. Perhaps for someone with pale blonde or white hair it would be, but I'm medium to light brown with gentle golden blonde highlights. I tried layering that brown Jane Iredale stick twice but felt I was pulling my eyelid skin too much to do that so I ordered my original black/brown choice again. I am so glad to have it back, it's perfect. And it's not bad for my skin with nasty chemicals. This stick has just the right amount of glide and is easy to control. I'm sticking with it from now on. You can easily go really light in application if you want to have a minimal look yet create some definition. I haven't found anything better for eyeliner. I'm totally satisfied & happy with it. I believe you would be also if you are the kind of woman who desires natural products as much as possible but you do use makeup. This one is top notch class, in both use and appearance. You may feel contentedly privileged to know about it, as I do.
Love1another
Verified Purchase
0 people found this helpful
Long-time favorite
Love the color. Lasts a long time. Also smooth, easy to apply. Pencil tends to split and splinter, however, when it gets toward the end.
LovelySkin Customer
Verified Purchase
0 people found this helpful
Pencil
Really liked it.
Bekki
Verified Purchase
0 people found this helpful
Eye pencil in Taupe
I like this eye pencil. I ordered in Taupe and it is a little lighter than I thought it would be. So I am a little bummed. It is more blonde than I thought it would be.
ShannonV
Verified Purchase
0 people found this helpful
Good Everyday Eyeliner
Love Jane Iredale products! The Midnight Blue was lovely and more interesting than basic black. This liner applied smoothly, but did not last long. It looks great if it doesn't smudge under your eyes, but unfortunately, it did smudge on me. It may be a tradeoff to get the clean ingredients.
LovelySkin Customer
Verified Purchase
0 people found this helpful
Easy to apply
I think Jane Iredale has reformulated their eye pencils, as they are softer and creamier than they used to be. In the past, they would crumble when you tried to use them and I have not had that problem with the last two pencils I purchased. I love them for tightlining and they don't irritate my eyes or shed particles into them.
BethD
Verified Purchase
0 people found this helpful
Goes on smooth
Jane Iredale always has good products and you can never go wrong.
JEF
Verified Purchase
0 people found this helpful
Good liner
This is a fairly soft pencil that will make a nice line or smudge softly. It is disappointing that it is extremely difficult to sharpen once the original point disappears. A lot of liner breaks off & the pencil splinters.
Oldster
Verified Purchase
0 people found this helpful
Great color that goes on smoothly!
I give this eyeliner 4 out of 5 stars because of the great color and how easily it is applied. I am able to “draw” the shape I want without it looking “caked-on.” One minus is that I must reapply in certain areas after awhile as it does seem to “wear off.”
MaintenancePro
Verified Purchase
0 people found this helpful
jane iredale Eye Pencil
Nice color, goes on smooth and stays on all day. I love the brown color, just right!
NewNewYorker
Verified Purchase
0 people found this helpful
A better than average pencil liner
I would likely order again.
Lindalee
Verified Purchase
0 people found this helpful
Bendable Eyeliner
Really allows it to be blended and smudged. Great for smokey eye makeup.
cait1988
Verified Purchase
0 people found this helpful
Good but does not stay
I love all things Jane! Great products. This does not make my eyes irritate however it does not stay very well.
MrsSensitivity
Verified Purchase
0 people found this helpful
Nice Shade
I like the white shade. Stays on 8 hrs Doesn't have glitter or shimmer, which is nice for mature eyes.
Denimsung
Verified Purchase
0 people found this helpful
Nice pencil!
I’d give it five stars if it didn’t smudge a bit even after setting it with powder.
LovelySkin Customer
Verified Purchase
0 people found this helpful
Doesn’t Pull on Eyelid
Love how creamy the eye liner is! It doesn’t pull at all when applying to eyes. Wish it was waterproof because it runs under my eyes after a few hours.
AnnMG
Verified Purchase
0 people found this helpful
jane iredale Eye Pencil
I bought the taupe pencil and I use it as a liner and brow pencil. It goes on very easily and has a great color and texture. Seems like the liner itself is quite soft and does not appear to last that long.
Karovd
Verified Purchase
0 people found this helpful
Jane iredale
This pencil is fast-paced because I have oily skin.
LovelySkin Customer
Verified Purchase
0 people found this helpful
Nice eye pencil
Easy to apply and long lasting.
LovelySkin Customer
Verified Purchase
0 people found this helpful
JI eye pencil
Goes on quite easily and non-irritating. Black/brown perfect color for my blue eyes
LovelySkin Customer
Verified Purchase
0 people found this helpful
Review Summary
Have you purchased this product? Write a Review
