Product Reviews for Jane Iredale Eye Pencil
Dermatologist owned & operated. Visit Schlessinger MD
Free 2-3 day delivery most orders, no minimums
LovelySkin
Today's Special Offer: FINAL HOURS: 25% Eminence Organics Savings on Select Products Shop Now
Return to Product Details
Jane Iredale Eyeliner Eye Pencil - Basic Black

Reviews For jane iredale Eye Pencil

$24.00
165 Reviews
February 04, 2022

Great Rich Color

This is a true brown, not brown/black. It goes on smooth and blends well.

Profile Photo

LovelySkin Customer

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

February 04, 2022

Highlight your Eyes!

This white pencil brightens your eyes. Looks natural and easy to do! Mistake proof eye highlighter.

Profile Photo

Magster

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

February 04, 2022

Easy to Apply

Love this pencil. Easy to apply by drawing on eyelid or using a brush to apply. Stays on all day with no smearing.

Profile Photo

susiesdavis

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

January 02, 2022

Love this eye pencil!

I love this eye pencil. I tried others and Jane's products are just better quality. I buy this one over and over again.

Profile Photo

mdilling67

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

November 12, 2021

Eye Pencil

Love this product. Leaves eyes looking natural with a smoky look. A must have!!!

Profile Photo

Glo

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

September 23, 2021

Great pencil

Love this product! It goes in smooth and blends well. My new go-to!

Profile Photo

LovelySkin Customer

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

July 28, 2021

Eye Pencil

Best eye pencil I’ve ever used. Goes on so smooth and easy. No comparison to drug store brands!

Profile Photo

CKK

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

July 19, 2021

Much to my surprise

I have many allergies and sensitive to many eye products but the pencil did not cause a reaction. I cannot explain anything except Jane Iredale products are indeed for those with sensitivities. I have the taupe eye shadow so how cool is this?

Profile Picture for Bobbi

Florence

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

July 09, 2021

My favorite eye pencil!

Soft pencil that is easy to control the line you want. Stays in place. The pencil last a long time. I’m a repeat customer of this pencil. The black/brown is a great basic to have in your makeup bag.

Profile Photo

LovelySkin Customer

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

July 03, 2021

Love This!

Love this eyeliner because it is applies well, is long lasting and does not smudge.

Profile Photo

LovelySkin Customer

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

May 23, 2021

Easy blue

Love the color and the ease of application. The pencil glides, doesn’t pull.

Profile Photo

DCC

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

April 11, 2021

Love this eye pencil

Love this eye pencil. There is no smearing or smudging with this pencil. It works great!

Profile Photo

LovelySkin Customer

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

March 23, 2021

Silky Application

I wanted an eyeliner that I could tight line with but was soft enough to smudge out and this worked really well. I can do sharp lines despite the softness and it doesn't irritate my eyes during the day.

Profile Photo

Klewi

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

March 14, 2021

Great eye pencil

This pencil goes on so smooth and stays in place all day. Will definitely purchase again and try other colors.

Profile Photo

JodiG

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

October 02, 2021

Good but does not stay

I love all things Jane! Great products. This does not make my eyes irritate however it does not stay very well.

Profile Photo

MrsSensitivity

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

September 04, 2021

Nice Shade

I like the white shade. Stays on 8 hrs Doesn't have glitter or shimmer, which is nice for mature eyes.

Profile Photo

Denimsung

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

July 11, 2021

Nice pencil!

I’d give it five stars if it didn’t smudge a bit even after setting it with powder.

Profile Photo

LovelySkin Customer

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

November 12, 2021

Mixed Feelings

In one sense I like this eyeliner in that the color is very natural, can easily control how light/heavy/dark of a line you want and it doesn't bother my eyes like so many eye liners do. On the other hand I'm disappointed that I can't just make one quick smooth line. I have to go back and forth in order to get an even line and throughout the day it starts to smudge and come off. May buy it again simply because I'm sensitive and would recommend for that reason only. Otherwise, not entirely sure.

Profile Photo

LovelySkin Customer

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

September 06, 2021

Very Average

There isn’t anything special about this eye liner. Unfortunately, it is not long wearing. Would not buy again.

Profile Photo

LovelySkin Customer

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

June 10, 2021

Its ok....

I LOVE Jane Iredale but these eye pencils for me are not that smooth. I buy them because I believe in the brand but wish they were more creamy.

Profile Picture for Cristina

LovelySkin Customer

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

Have you purchased this product? Write a Review


Return to the top
402-697-1100
Need Help?
Let's Chat
Customer Care Hours
Mon - Fri 9 - 5 p.m. CT
Sat (chat only) 9 - 3 p.m. CT
Sun / Holidays Closed
Call or Text:402-697-1100